[MGSA-L] Syriza vs. Xrisi Aygi column Του Νικου Χρυσολωρα

Dimitris Papanikolaou dimitris.papanikolaou at mod-langs.ox.ac.uk
Fri Oct 5 09:18:14 PDT 2012


Just like Aristide Caratzas and Neni Panourgia, I also found the comment that 'many of those who speak and write about Greece no nothing about Greece', an ad hominem remark, to the extent that it seemed targeting members of this list. This type of remarks seem awkward in this list, and thus I share Neni's frustration.

At the same time, Dr. Caratzas, I find your last paragraph, with mentions of Hezbolah, drug dealers and human traffickers, extremely problematic, in that it is not supported by either research or references, and it is rhetorically shaped in a way that, to some readers, it may create the image of a Syriza engaging in this type of links and negotiations. This is the type of rhetoric that we should avoid, I feel.

Last, but not least, may I draw your attention to a strong article by Giorgos Katsampekis, on Laclau and our discussion in the MGSA list. Just published on Rednotebook. And certainly worth a read.

http://www.rednotebook.gr/details.php?id=6958


Dimitris

________________________________
From: mgsa-l-bounces at uci.edu [mgsa-l-bounces at uci.edu] on behalf of Aristide Caratzas [acaratzas at gmail.com]
Sent: 05 October 2012 09:55
To: MGSA List
Cc: Neni Panourgia
Subject: Re: [MGSA-L] Syriza vs. Xrisi Aygi column Του Νικου Χρυσολωρα

Two points on the remarks below:

1. As I have understood it as a member of MGSA on- and off for two or more decades, and a subscriber to this list nearly since its inception, ad hominem remarks have no place here, however couched the remarks below inappropriate as they could be interpreted as demeaning (whatever their "Classical" cover). That is the stuff for defamation and libel actions, to which I referred in a previous posting.

2. In fact Mr Grammenos reported as an eyewitness to a particular event, in other words he provided us with one piece of evidence about the situation in Greece; many of us understand scholarship to include the proper recording of evidence and its subsequent interpretation. Much more of this basic recording of evidence work is necessary as relates to the situation in Greece...

As I understand what Mr Grammenos reported, the high school students sang a song that culminated in the threat of the use of violence (molotov cocktails and explosives). The recent thread in our list to which he referred touched on exactly that point, allegations about the use of violence by Chryse Auge over the last few months, and by the Anarcho-Leftists (including by factions of Syriza) over the last few years.

It would seem to me that a discussion about the loss of legitimacy by the major parties in Greece, the evolution of political activity towards the extremes of left and right, the readiness to use violence (and to ally with organized criminal groups [such as drug dealers and human traffickers], to give cover to foreign extremists and maintain links with Hezbollah and similar groups), all are (related) subjects which should be at the very heart of the discussions and the necessary scholarly work by members of our association.

Aristide Caratzas


On Oct 5, 2012, at 4:05 AM, Neni Panourgia wrote:

Indeed, Mr Grammenos, indeed, many of those who speak and write about Greece, know nothing about Greece. Perfect self-awareness. You would have made Socrates happy, indeed.

many of those who speak and write about Greece, know nothing about Greece.

np/

On 10/3/2012 8:08 PM, athanasios grammenos wrote:
Some 150 students of a North Attica High School, protested today outside the Town Hall of their Municipality. The reason was a problem with the transportation of the students across the region, because of the budget. They went there, despite the fact that the responsible is the Regional Director and not the Mayor.
However, the most interesting, is what I witnessed that they were singing. It was irrelevant to their main cause but it symbolized something related to the conversation about SYRIZA and Golden Dawn.

Here it is:

Ψωμί-παιδεία-ελευθερία (bread-education-liberty)
πουλήστε τα γραφεία σας να πάρουμε βιβλία (sell your offices and let us buy books)

πάρτε το χαμπάρι δεν φεύγουμε απο δω (get it, we're going nowhere)
θα κανουμ' ανω-κάτω το δημαρχείο αυτό (we'll do a mess to this Town Hall)

το μέλλον μας δεν είναι τα ναρκωτικά (drugs is not our future)
είναι οι μολότωφ και τα εκρηκτικά. (our future is molotov [bombs] and explosives)
Unfortunately, many of those who speak and write about Greece, know nothing about Greece.
AG



2012/9/30 Christos D. Katsetos <cd_katsetos at yahoo.com<mailto:cd_katsetos at yahoo.com>>
In his circuitous, overly didactic, and hubris-laden posts, Dr Nikos Chrysoloras,
journalist and EU correspondent of the Athens daily "Kathimerini," is going off on
tangents, effectively avoiding direct confrontation of the main issue at hand, which
is the legitimacy of dissent in the Greek political system.

At issue is the journalist's statement that "both SYRIZA and Chrissi Avgi's populist
discourses question the legitimacy of democratically elected governments."
Here the legitimacy of dissenting opinion is replaced by the embellished phrase
"populist discourses [which] question the legitimacy of democratically elected
governments." The author is using Laclau's analysis of the logic of equivalence
operative in populist demands to justify his assertion that Golden Dawn and the
Coalition of the Radical Left party (SYRIZA) are structurally "equivalent" (insinuating
that the convergence of BOTH extreme parties is threatening Greek democracy).

As such, the militancy of the extreme right, which promotes hate mongering and
perverts traditional Greek patriotism, is put on the same footing as the social and
human rights activism embraced by the leftist SYRIZA party. In my view, this is a
deliberate and self-serving linkage distortion. It is apparent that the journalist's mission
is to nullify the legitimacy of principled dissent expressed by political forces that
oppose the austerity measures and want to re-negotiate the terms of Greece's bailout package. Arguably, the primary target here is not the ultranationalist party but the
Coalition of the Radical Left party (SYRIZA) that has the potential of governing the
country in the not too distant future.

What we are witnessing in the Greek mass media nowadays is the emergence
of certain aspiring pundits with academic credentials, some of whom are running
regular columns in certain influential newspapers, who are getting away with
provocative and outrageous statements by adopting an arrogant style of analysis
based on the framework and communication strategies dictated by political
expedience.

This confrontational approach only serves to further disenfranchise a growing
segment of the population, deepen divisions in the Greek society, and create
the conditions for the revival of a bitter and potentially violent civil conflict.

And yet, a growing number of Greeks (without Left-wing affiliations) are opposed
to this divisive rhetoric and believe that Greece's path to recovery will be achieved
only through national unity and reconciliation.

-- See Prof Sir Basil Markesinis' interview aired on ET3 (Greek Public Television)
on May 2, 2012  http://vimeo.com/41375667

-- See Prof Markesinis' latest call for National Reconciliation.
http://www.antibaro.gr/article/5460


Christos D. Katsetos, MD, PhD, FRCPath
http://www.drexelmed.edu/Home/AboutOurFaculty/ChristosKatsetos.aspx
http://www.stchristophershospital.com/find-a-physician/120
________________________________
From: Nikos Chrysoloras <nikos.chrysoloras at gmail.com<mailto:nikos.chrysoloras at gmail.com>>
To: mgsa-l at uci.edu<mailto:mgsa-l at uci.edu>
Sent: Friday, September 28, 2012 4:20 AM

Subject: Re: [MGSA-L] Syriza vs. Xrisi Aygi column Του Νικου Χρυσολωρα

http://maillists.uci.edu/mailman/public/mgsa-l/2012-September/014432.html

_______________________________________________
List-Info: https://maillists.uci.edu/mailman/listinfo/mgsa-l




--
-- --
And if you find her poor, Ithaka won’t have fooled you.
Wise as you will have become, so full of experience,
you will have understood by then what these Ithakas mean.

Constantine Cavafy

«Εσμέν Έλληνες το γένος, ως η τε φωνή και η πάτριος παιδεία μαρτυρεί»
Πλήθων Γεμιστός




_______________________________________________
List-Info: https://maillists.uci.edu/mailman/listinfo/mgsa-l



--
________________________
Professor Neni Panourgiá

2012-2013
Visiting Associate Professor
Bard College
Anthropology Department
Hopson 301
Warden's Hall, PO Box 5000
Annandale-on-Hudson, NY 12504
(845) 752-7217

ICLS
Heyman Center for the Humanities,
Columbia University,
New York, NY 10027

Dangerous Citizens. The Greek Left and the Terror of the State
www.dangerouscitizens.columbia.edu<http://www.dangerouscitizens.columbia.edu/>

Ethnographica Moralia Experiments in Interpretive Anthropology
www.fordhampress.com/detail.html?id=9780823228874<http://www.fordhampress.com/detail.html?id=9780823228874>







_______________________________________________
List-Info: https://maillists.uci.edu/mailman/listinfo/mgsa-l

Aristide D. Caratzas
Telephone: 30-697-228-5442
acaratzas at gmail.com<mailto:acaratzas at gmail.com>





-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://maillists.uci.edu/mailman/public/mgsa-l/attachments/20121005/c0d6b999/attachment.html 


More information about the MGSA-L mailing list